RSS Feed

The Atrocity That is Birthday Cake

Part of this year's twenty. Geez, I'm getting old.

“Spittle, anyone?”

It is a well documented fact that while The Queen has two birthdays a year and dogs have 7 birthdays a year (or however that works), I don’t have any birthdays at all. I gave them up in a bid to remain forever young and free of birthday remorse (a bit like buyer’s remorse but with more wrinkles) so it’s been a while since I had all the trappings of a birthday party foisted upon me, but I see it happen to others and that is why I am all too familiar and repulsed by the atrocity that is ‘the birthday cake’.

There’s an old joke which theorises that birthday cake causes wrinkles; the more birthday cakes you eat, the older and wrinklier you become. You may laugh, but it’s solid logic and something the face cream purveyors would like to keep out of the public consciousness. You can scoff, or you can add “birthday cake” to your list of allergies like a pathetic narcissist and have a ridiculous medic alert bracelet made up. I’m having my bracelet gold plated. Anyway, an aversion to the aging process is not my only reason for bearing more than a disliking for the edible candle-topped treat, the reasons are many.

Most cakes are simply delicious, that is, they are simple and they are delicious. When I make a cake at home – HAHAHA oh god, I almost choked on my own kidneys from laughing then – when you buy a cake from the shop, you select one that has clearly been crafted to contain at least 80% cake, with a 20% allowance for filling, frosting, icing, kittens, whatever. This is the ideal ratio for a cake of such deliciousness that you want to buy it dinner and take it to the cinema to try getting its crumbs on your crotch in the back row. The birthday cake flouts this basic cakey ratio and instead, goes for outright style over substance abuse.

The average birthday cake now bears little resemblance to a real cake. It is a grotesque beast of moist fondant sugar, containing more artificial colouring and sparkles than a chorus line, with a tiny dried out heart of crumbs. Once your knife slices through the novelty outer caterpillar/wardrobe/naked man, you can hear the sorry “pfffft” of the cake’s dead soul escaping like the dying fart of a pensioner stranded in the Sahara. Statuesque it may be, cake it is not.

Leaving aside the vile tasting replica fondant Ford Model T with life size sugared chauffeur, my birthday cake issue comes in an audible form and that is the singing. Ever since I was a child I have loved singing and making a complete tit out of myself, whether in the musicals of my school days or more recently on the streets of London at 3am, but when it comes to singing ‘Happy Birthday’ in a bar or the office, I suddenly find I’m as eager as a first time offender soaping up in the prison showers.

No matter how dulcet your singing voice, no matter how perfect your pitch, as soon as you amble across an open plan office behind a flaming slab of E-numbers, with 8-10 other reluctant choristers, you suddenly find that upon opening your mouth, all that falls out is a sound not dissimilar to the noise a car wreck makes when being dragged across all the broken glass in Hell. Coupled with the fact that not a single one in your a capella birthday band has managed to find a note  previously known to mankind (or each other) and your heart felt tribute sounds more like a Satanic curse of eternal drudgery upon the embarrassed birthday boy or girl, inflicted at faux enthusiastically full volume.

And so we come to the part of the birthday cake ritual I despise the most. Above the ageing, above the sugar craft vulgarity, above the tuneless caterwauling, it’s the candles. What, you ask, could be so offensive about having a little miniature fire atop this block of wet sugar, one for each year you wish to humiliate the recipient? Well, I have nothing so much against the candles, after all, every girl knows that candlelight is the most flattering glow there is, other than the post-coital variety. No, what it is about the blazing cake toppers is the method with which they are extinguished.

“Here you are, have a nice tasty cake to share with your chums, but before you give them all a big slice, why not cover it with an even misting of spittle.”

Think I’m being daft? It’s science. Every time you blow from your mouth, lots of particles of spit and whatever else you keep in there (lunch, fag butts, loose change) comes spraying out to encase everything that lies in its path, in this case, the tasty treat you’re about to invite your nearest and dearest to share with you. This is worse tenfold for children’s birthday parties, where sloppy-chopped ankle biters all want to get a piece of the spittle spraying action and aim great gobbits of saliva and half chewed sausage roll, via the medium of a noisy raspberry, directly at the fire risk en mass. Seconds, anyone? Even porn films display a greater respect for hygiene and bodily fluids than the average birthday cake receives.

Given the fact the average birthday cake carries a high risk of disappointment, diabetes, public humiliation and herpes (not to mention the ageing effect),  it’s a wonder this atrocious tradition has continued to exist for so long unchallenged. I think I’ll stick to the safe and healthy option and celebrate people’s birthdays by drinking my way through them, in silence and far from mists of spittle.

About prettyfeetpoptoe

I live in London and have both my own legs so I am fortunate enough to get out and about on occasion. I form many views on the things that I see and do and love nothing better than a session of linguistic gymnastics in order to share these views.

17 responses »

  1. Hear, hear. Hate the song, hate the frosting, hate the spitting. Don’t mind the birthday – just would rather have something with less than 1″ of sugar on top and something actually tasty besides. PS fondant is the devil.

  2. Being diabetic, I no longer partake of cake, but, now, I am not sure I could even if I was cured.
    Thanks for removing my guilt over saying, “No.”

  3. Adventures in Kevin's World

    I eat cake once a year – on my birthday. I love my fudge marble cake with peanut butter frosting. An annual tradition since I was 4 or 5. Since you’re from the other side of the atlantic you probably think peanut butter frosting sounds gross. But you’d be so wrong! 🙂

    But I’m with you 100% on the blowing out candles bit. Even before I became a germaphobe in my old age I always thought it was gross.

    • missy amber

      At the risk of Ms Poptoe disowning me, PLEASE can you post the recipe for the peanut butter frosting! That sounds utterly genius! I’m sadly addicted to PBJ on toast for breakfast, which is terribly un-English of me, and as my birthday is coming up shortly, I reckon a PBJ themed cake for me to slobber all over would be heaven.
      Poptoe, my dearest. You know I have anklebiters, so the cake thing has to happen chez Missy A. Plus, my cakes are always cakey and delicious and disappointment/fondant horror free. But I shall be banning the singing. Jesus, can they not at least decide on a key before they start?

      • Adventures in Kevin's World

        Converting the english, one blogger at a time….
        Unfortunately I lost my mom’s recipe long ago, so I just try different ones off the net every year. There’s a million variations, all involving peanut butter, milk or cream, confectioner’s sugar, and butter. (very healthy, yes?). I suggest going with one that has a little less sugar – some recipes can be sickeningly sweet.

        Enjoy! It’s yummy.

  4. I’m not a massive cake fan, so when I was young my mum coined onto the idea of giving me ‘Birthday Chocolate’ i.e. a large slab of family chocolate, conveniently wrapped (as to avoid the spittle). Unsure why it hasnt taken off yet.

    • I got given a huge bag of posh chocolate for my birthday once and I was ecstatic. The dog ate the lot. I’m not ashamed to say I was gutted that the beast didn’t succumb to the poisonous effect chocolate has on hounds.

  5. Phlegm cake is a tradition in our family, Lovely with gob custard. Me dear old ma and pa died of Consumption but that never stopped us.

  6. I like cake, I usually skip the candles though because seriously what am I, 10? And this year my boyfriend was in the hospital recovering from surgery, my family doesn’t live here, so it was just me and the dog celebrating my birthday (it was Easter long weekend so I had my party the weekend before – I figured people might want to celebrate Easter with their families or something!) But this year I had birthday pie! I thought that was a good idea, Mercy did too – here she is suggesting that I share with her:

  7. To each his own I suppose. In the back row of the theatre I would much prefer moist fondant sugar to crumbs.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: